New SAT vs. ACT

Colleges will accept either the New SAT or the ACT or both. So which one should you take?

It's all about the numbers. Some students end up scoring substantially higher on the SAT; others do better on the ACT. In lieu of a crystal ball, we have got The Princeton Review StartUp Test – a tool designed to help you determine which test is a better fit with your abilities.

ACT questions tend to be more straightforward.

ACT questions are often easier to understand on first read. On the New SAT, you may need to spend time figuring out what you're being asked before you can start solving the problem.

After the 2016 changes, the SAT Writing and Language Test has become more like the ACT English Test. However, the ACT remains more straightforward on the whole. The questions on SAT Reading are often more abstract than those on ACT Reading.

The New SAT contains questions that have been specially designed to serve some specific purpose: for example, the “paired questions” on the Reading Test to judge command of evidence, and specially designed math questions to judge understanding of math concepts.

The New SAT still requires a wider vocabulary.

While neither exam tests esoteric or difficult words directly, the passages on the SAT tend to be more complex and dense, and they are full of words that many students would not know. Students who have better vocabulary skills and who are able to understand these passages have an advantage on the SAT.

The ACT has more Science, than the New SAT

The ACT has a separate Science section. But you don't need to know anything about amoebas or chemical reactions for ACT Science. It tests your Science reading and reasoning skills: with rare exceptions, the answers to all the questions are in the passages.

The New SAT does not have a Science section, but it does provide a separate Cross Test Score for Analysis in Science. This Cross Test Score is based on selected questions in the Reading, the Writing and Language, and the Math tests. Two of the five passages on the Reading Test are on Science topics.

While neither the ACT nor the SAT requires much Science knowledge, the separate section means that the ACT overall has more Science content than does the SAT.

The New SAT has more History and Social Studies than the ACT.

As for Science, the New SAT provides a separate Cross Test Score for Analysis in History/Social Studies, based on select questions on the Reading Test, the Writing and Language Test, and the Math Test. Two of the five passages in the Reading section relate to History/Social Studies topics. The SAT has as much History/Social Studies as Science, and the History/Social Studies content on the SAT is of a higher level than that on the ACT.

The ACT tests a greater number of Math concepts.

The ACT syllabus includes more Math topics than the new SAT: for example, matrices and logarithms. That said, the ACT Math section is not necessarily harder, since many students find ACT questions more straightforward than those on the SAT.

The essay tasks are very different.

On the SAT, students are given a long, well-constructed speech or article to read and analyze. Using evidence from the text, students have to explain how the author builds the argument and how the author persuades or influences the audience. Separate scores are awarded for three parameters – Reading, Analysis, and Writing.

On the ACT, students are presented with a paragraph about an issue and three different perspectives on that issue. Students have to analyze the given perspectives and have to present their own perspective along with justification. Separate scores are awarded for four parameters – Ideas and Analysis, Development and Support, Organization, and Language Use and Conventions.

As of 2016, the essay is 'optional' on both the New SAT and the ACT.

The ACT is scored on a scale of 1-36 and the SAT is scored on a scale of 400-1600.

Three points on the SAT isn’t a big deal, but three points on the ACT could be the difference between your target school and your dream school.

Your performance affects your overall score differently on the SAT and the ACT.

As the Composite Score on the ACT is an average of the scores on the four tests, a small difference in the performance in one test may not change the Composite Score. However, on the New SAT, any difference in performance in any section will directly reflect in the Composite Score as the Composite Score is the sum total of the two Sectional Scores. So, if you happen to be weak in one particular area, the ACT may suit you better than the SAT: this weakness will not reflect so much in your composite score; especially because colleges have traditionally paid more attention to the ACT composite score rather than to the ACT score breakup.

To register for the Princeton Review StartUp Test for free please click here .


SAT is a trademark registered and owned by the College Board, which is not affiliated with and does not endorse this product.

VIDEOS | View All


Copyright © Manya Group 2015. All Rights Reserved | The Princeton Review is not affiliated with Princeton University.